Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 92225
Wrong multi-Sheet zone selection
Last modified: 2013-01-29 21:45:19 UTC
Sometimes, it could be shine to calculate a SUM or something else on a large number of sheets. Sheet TOTAL, cell A1: formula =SUM(begin.A1:end.A1) when workbook contains following sheets: - TOTAL - BEGIN - A - B - C - ... - END Expected user-interface operation to enter this formula is: - sheet TOTAL, select cell A1 - type "=SUM(" on keyboard - with the mouse, select sheet BEGIN, press shift and clic sheet END to select sheets BEGIN, A, B, C, ..., and END - clic cell A1 - press ")" + enter on keyboard When this user-interface operation is done, the resulting formula is: "=SUM (BEGIN.A1)" instead of "=SUM(BEGIN.A1:END.A1)". The user-interface operation to get the correct formula is: - sheet TOTAL, select cell A1 - type "=SUM(" on keyboard - with the mouse, select sheet BEGIN, clic A1 cell - press shift and clic sheet END to select sheets BEGIN, A, B, C, ..., and END - clic sheet "END" to make it active (name "END" in bold", but sheets BEGIN to END still selected) - press shift and clic cell A1 (in END sheet) - press ")" + enter on keyboard --> not very user-friendly...
In OOO300_m3 On WinXP,it exists. But I think the current way ,which can get the correct formula, seems more reasonable and logical. So I believe this issue is INVALID. The user-interface operation to get the correct formula is: - sheet TOTAL, select cell A1 - type "=SUM(" on keyboard - with the mouse, select sheet BEGIN, clic A1 cell - press Shift and clic sheet END to select sheets BEGIN, A, B, C, ..., and END - clic sheet "END" to make it active (name "END" in bold", but sheets BEGIN to END still selected) - type ":" and clic cell A1 (in END sheet) - type ")" + press Enter on keyboard
Hi, In this case, you needn't select the sheets, just do like this: - sheet TOTAL, select cell A1 - type "=SUM(" on keyboard - with the mouse, select sheet BEGIN, press shift and click A1 cell - click sheet "END", press shift and clic cell A1 (in END sheet) - press ")" + enter on keyboard I think your proposal is real a good one which is adopted by MS. Maybe it could be a enhencement to improve interoperability, but not a defect.
Thanks for your comments. You're right I'm MS intoxicated... and Oo UI you explain to me is good too (because with MS UI let us understand it's possible to have a multi-sheet selection with hole inside, but it doesn't: it must be from BEGIN to END, like with Oo). I propose to delete this Issue. Priority set to P5.