Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 32684
Export to CSV
Last modified: 2013-08-07 15:12:27 UTC
I think that it would be very useful to have either a choice when you save as CSV to choose save as copy, or to have a choice in the export dialog to export CSV as well as PDF. When I work with a spreadsheet and want to save a CSV file, I don't want my working document to change to a CSV document, I just want to save a copy. Another option might be to have a menu choice and toolbar icon for save as copy. Thanks
Hi Bettina, one for you. Frank
I think this could be generalised to other exportable formats. I rarely want to save anything but ODF for myself, but sometimes I need to export in order to communicate with others. They get a copy and then I want to continue working in native format. I always look under File->export... first when I want to do this. It also simply makes sense to have all savable formats under export...
I'm going to echo this request since I came here to file this as a feature request. Because CSV doesn't support most formatting, I typically want to EXPORT to it, rather than Save As...
As the csv is really an intermediary transport file used to transfer one sheet of data from the spreadsheet to another program, I strongly support adding the CSV-format to the EXPORT-possibilities. The csv can't support formatting nor formulas, BUT most importantly, only the *active sheet* is exported, so it is really ONLY an export, NOT a SAVE AS-functionality. I therefore strongly suggest to add this option to the EXPORT-dialog. This has some practical consequences. Basically, it is impossible to perform any sound statistics in Calc. At the same time, the ODF-format has become too complex to implement accurate readers (that mimic all its bugs and limitations) in professional statistic packages. It is therefore imperative to use a simple format for data-transfer, and csv is simply the best suited one (tab-delimited data is another one). I therefore strongly hope that this enhancement gets implemented in Calc. Basically, the export-dialog should have both PDF and CSV as options. Selecting CSV should export the active sheet, using the sheet-name as default name. The status of the ods-file should not change (i.e. do not set changed status). That's it.
This issue has been discussed by UX for years now and having dug around in 3-4 years of discussions and lists I'm stunned by how such a practical feature has been crushed under the albatros of "Oh but we can't do it THAT way because we have to argue about a better way to do it." I'm all for good UI design, the importance of consistent UI, and respecting workflows... but after 3 years of A) having to search the forums for a visual basic script to do something a simple as "export this file to format FOO so I can send it to another Program/Collaborator, then continue working" B) new users losing data because they don't understand the difference between "You're working with data that won't be saved when you hit 'Save'" It's time to accept a quite likely sub-optimal but pragmatic solution (aka: a "hack") to get it done. I'll start digging around in code to try and do it, but I doubt it'll be the most efficient solution.
To grep the issues easier via "requirements" I put the issues currently lying on my owner to the owner "requirements".